Disc contains an mp3 file which can be copied to a portable music player as well as a pdf of the program. Hitchens doubts there is a god because the required evidence is missing. Jan and i used to sit in those very bleachers right over there watching our son john run. Everything that begins to exist has a cause of its existence. How religion poisons everythingat virginia commonwealth university. May 14, 2016 a new book says the impious author of god is not great might have been exploring faith before he died in 2011. Hitchens never claimed that there was no god, only that theists had a burden of proof to prove god s existence by virtue of our claim that god exists. You might be surprised that hitchens doesnt take the strident atheist position that would have let more sparks fly. On april 4, 2009, william lane craig and christopher hitchens met at biola university to debate the question of god s existence. That night we had a spirited but rambling exchange. Theologian douglas wilson and atheist christopher hitchens, authors whose books are already part of a larger debate on whether religion is pernicious, agreed to discuss their views on whether christianity itself has benefited the world. Craig knows there is a god because he has a feeling inside. Now the numinous and the transcendent are exactly what we believers mean by god. Fact is atheists will have a tough time to prove that god does not exist and it.
Hitchens could read technical manuals and keep an audience spell bound, so our audience was entertained. How religion poisons everything, at virginia commonwealth university. There sinnottarmstrong opened by arguing against the existence of god, and then craig criticized sinnottarmstrongs arguments and offered argu. Christopher hitchens debates william lane craig at biola u. Dec 20, 2014 what we are seeking to do this evening is to narrow the discussion just a bit and hence that the name of this debate the god delusion debate. You can be beaten with the arguments, that is you can be refuted or your arguments shown invalid or just wrong but th. Therefore, the universe has a cause of its existence. Christopher hitchens argument over religion was largely. But as with most rabid aetheists, there can be no allowance for discussion on a reasoned basis for this type of evidence. William lane craig, believe that there are solid reasons to believe in god, and during the course of this 2009 debate at biola university he outlines those arguments. On march 21, william lane craig and christopher hitchens were part of a larger, ctsponsored panel discussion on does the god of christianity exist, and what difference does it make.
Renowned apologist and atheist debate does god exist. Be specific name the premises and the conclusion, in good form. Craigs defenders class today who read this summary of the craig hitchens debate and said it was perfectly on the money according to my source. Hitchens mainly is concerned with refuting the monotheism of judaism, christianity, and islam although he does spend chapter 14 on eastern religions, which are not usually monotheistic.
It was as if he wasnt up to his usual standard tired if you like. See frank turek debate atheist christopher hitchens author of god is not great. Apr 21, 20 i have watched that debate a few times and i have a comment regarding it. Hitchens, richard dawkins, my friend william lobdell and others who have once again put at the center of the public stage the question of whether or not god does exist and. It is bad to fear things that we ought not fearthings like the dark, small insects that cannot harm you, or mayonnaise. Live coverage of the christopher hitchens william lane craig debate on does god exist. Craig is one of the worlds foremost christian apologists.
He hardly breaks a sweat in arguing that god does not exist. During the christian book expo in dallas last month, craig and hitchens took opposing sides in a panel examining does the god of christianity exist, and. Many theists and atheists alike agree on this point. Doug tennapel at big hollywood comes to almost opposite conclusions from yours about the hitchens vs. This debate will feature and will focus on the book the god delusion and richards assertions therein over and against the christian faith. University of california, irvine, february 11, 1985. Nearly 40 blogs were posted during and after the event. Hitchens next argument involves the christian belief that we must accept the. It seemed more of a lets bash the god believers event than a reasoned debate.
Hitchens, presumably he presented his case completely in the first 3 sections of the debate. The debate between craig and hitchens over the existence of god is legendary. It is the best of timesit is the best of times for those who like to argue about god in the public square, largely because of the rise of new atheists such as mr. I am very excited to be participating in this debate tonight. Bonus features include the predebate press conference, a question and answer session, and interviews with craig and hitchens. Sean carroll vs william lane craig god and cosmology 2014. Ill start by addressing gods existence and then turn to gods goodness. The attempt to prove the existence of god fails again.
A note on the craighitchens debate psychology today. William lane craig debates truth according to scripture. Craigs defenders class today who read this summary of the craighitchens debate and said it was perfectly on the money according to my source. May 29, 2014 ive listened to this debate over and over and over, and it doesnt get old. On september 9, 2008, frank turek debated atheist christopher hitchens, author of god is not great. Hitchens was the author, coauthor, editor, or coeditor of over 30 books, including five collections of essays on culture, politics, and literature. I propose this to be my final post to this discussion as it is becoming fly paper. Debate william lane craig vs christopher hitchens does god exist. But there is one other important sponsor, and that is the program that i direct. Who won in the does god exist debate between william lane. Richard dawkins vesves christopher hitchens debate the best documentary ever duration. Nov 09, 2010 but i accept the ontological challenge and i accept it in this way.
Topics 2010, christopher hitchens, william dembski, debate, religion, atheism. Craig won the argument he was the only one who even presented a formal argument, hitchens won the debate. Given the idea that god either does exist or does not exist. Debate william lane craig vs christopher hitchens does. Apr 06, 2009 william lane craig debates christopher hitchens on the subject. William lane craig and outspoken atheist christopher hitchens will be debating the question does god exist. Does god exist debate successful and encourages dialogue. Watch our debate at the university of notre dame and tell me what you. Christopher hitchens was shaky in his atheism, new book. The late christopher hitchens and i did 10 or so debates on god and christianity. Christopher hitchens opened with an argument that dr. Nov 23, 2010 intelligent design proponent william dembski and famed atheist christopher hitchens disputed the existence of a benevolent god in a recent debate now posted online. Hitchens allowed turek to get away with pseudo scientific claims and did not in my opinion respond effectively.
But as even one of the atheist organizers of the event admitted, he rarely directly engaged my arguments for god during the debate. A summary of the arguments made during the debate can be found here. Hitchensturek debate video cross examined christian. Wc william lane craig, ch christopher hitchens wc opening speech. Blogger doug tennapel wrote his view of the debate on big hollywood blog, does god exist. Ravi zacharias international ministries does god exist. Tuesday, 28 2008 frank turek, coauthor of i dont have enough faith to be an atheist, and christopher hitchens, author of god is not. Not to say, his argument for x and y, while completely fallacious, convinced 37 viewers on twitter that god exists. It isthe issue is would jesus have been a guard at auschwitz because insofar as people who claim to be his followers were guards at auschwitz, they were acting inconsistently and in defiance of the ethic of jesus of nazareth. Stein subjective claims made about the experience of inner satisfaction or peace claims that are made in earnest by both christians and atheists in their literature and promotional claims made about the superiority of christianity or atheism. I find any arguments in favor to be fallacious or unconvincing. I give it two stars because craig does debate on some other topics of philosophy and theology fairly well but the blending of evolution evilsolution and the bible undermined god s word and craigs ability to help hitchens understand the true meaning of the gospel, good news, the lord has overcome death and holds life in his very hands. Craig had the obligation to prove god exists with some amount of certainty.
Dr craig and hitchens debate the evidence for the existence of god. Hitchens argument only gained the approval of 31 nobel laureates. But like richard dawkins, stephen hawkings and others, his conclusions were wrong and his full. Hitchensturek debate cross examined christian apologetic. He says that the opposition reminds him of his adolescent self, the worst person he ever knew. Unfortunately, when mcgrath does explicitly comment on hitchens comments about the death of christ, he ends up sounding a bit like the type of religious believer that hitchens describes in 1, and he does not capitalize on hitchens doublespeak here. Sep 10, 2008 on tuesday night, i debated atheist christopher hitchens, author of god is not great.
Craig, we have yet to do a podcast on the hitchens debate 1. There is something wrong with a pedestrian who does not have the healthy fear of getting run over that motivates him to look both ways before crossing the street. Hey, can you list for me the arguments that hitchens gave in defense of the claim god does not exist. Hitchens politely tears him a new one in this deabte. Hazen introduces moderator hugh hewitt, who outlines the rules for the debate and introduces hitchens and craigcraig. Below is their exchange, one in a series that will appear on our website over the course of this month. Hitchens dembski debate nov 2010 10 of 10 download. The only person ever to have any real dealings with that which does not exist is our creator god who made this universe and us out of nothing. Peter hitchens opens by stating that he hates this argument.
Hitchens says what he doesnt believe in is the supernatural. Sharpton should have come to the table with his proofs. Ive never seen any positive evidence for the existence of god ill go so far as to say that god does not exist craig. On tuesday night, i debated atheist christopher hitchens, author of god is not great.
Given the idea that god either does exist or does not exist, hitch thinks doubt is the better. May 07, 2007 hitchens, though sharpton has his correctly pegged as a conservative visavis iraq, should not have engaged the man in this discursive debate. To win a debate, you need to make some arguments for your claim, otherwise you lose the debate. This twohour debate aired on tv in two onehour segments, but you get the entire debate on one dvd. Does god exist william lane craig debates christopher. Who won in the does god exist debate between william. There is plenty of evidence for the validity of the bible and for a 6,000 year old earth.
William lane craig shares his thoughts on christopher hitchens and the new atheism movement or brights after their famous debate. Michael ruse, a noted agnostic philosopher of science, explains, the position of the modern evolutionist. A live webcast of the event will be shown, and can be purchased here. Greg koukl if god is allpowerful, why does evil exist. I am astounded that anyone could consider that hitchens in any way lost this debate, unless you allow that craig is free to redefine the topic and ground rules of debate to please himself. Christopher eric hitchens april 1949 15 december 2011 was an englishamerican author, philosopher, columnist, essayist, orator, journalist, and social critic. To say, hitchens points x and z were unconvincing, and w.
If god does not exist, then objective moral values do not exist. Dembski the existence of god good morning and thanks for this opportunity to debate the existence and goodness of god. Has christopher hitchens ever lost an argument or debate. Turek, virginia commonwealth university christopher hitchens vs.
It must do because it is so real to those who believe in it. The association of the term, einsteins fudge factor, with lambda was not originated by me so i will leave objectors to argue with stem etc al. Charleston nelson nevada new mexico red rock rio grande gorge taos. However, in the does god exist debate with frank turek, hitchens missed quite a few verbal punches. Preface xi church in eden prairie, minnesota on april 1, 2000. Mar 03, 2019 no reasons to believe that god does not exist ch withholds belief in god. Christopher hitchens vs william lane craig debate audio. A few hours ago i had the opportunity to debate christopher hitchens on the subject of his recent bestseller. The burden isnt on the atheist in the debate to show god doesnt exist.
Hitchens could then have simply shot them down, one by one. What is the evidence foragainst the existence of god. The basic question framing the debate is does god exist. Summary of the william lane craig vs christopher hitchens debate. The late hitchens was a leading spokesman for the new atheism movement. Also, christian post published an article on tuesday, april 7, renowned apologist and atheist debate does god exist. Summary of the william lane craig vs christopher hitchens.
1362 538 84 692 357 508 30 611 545 318 590 340 1085 1264 1339 299 1128 1448 6 756 753 342 72 415 277 498 1452 627 226 180 634 232 699 964 769 414 372 51 705